We can pretty much sum up what we think of maddox’s hate for the iPhone - wow. You would think the iPhone actually did this guy wrong - like banging his wife and his sister at the same time. You really should check out this guy’s rant about how much he loves his Nokia E70 and how much the iPhone is the result of some defecation that’s apparently on our face as well. We’ve noticed a good amount of iPhone “hating” in the recent weeks, but this is by far the angriest.
We’d like to take this opportunity to point out the critical flaw in all these iPhone haters’ arguments. Well, they are critical flaws - plural. We’re not Apple fanboys (well, some of us are), but for the most part, we are fans of the iPhone because of the design - not it’s features. Our judgements are based on rational thought and objective reasoning - taking into account the pros and cons.

First off, this is Apple’s first phone. Yes, they’ve been making consumer devices for years, but this is their first foray into an ultra-competitive and cut-throat market. All these other phones that people compare to the iPhone are made by companies with years of mobile phone experience tucked under their belts. If BMW had never made a single automobile, and tomorrow they launched a new 3-series that was controlled by the driver’s thoughts, and it sold like hotcakes, would anybody talk smack about it not having a spare tire? Of course not. The control interface’s seamless integration with the human interface would take center stage. Of course, those people that were put-off by the high sticker-price would find faults, but that’s what closed-minded people do - they latch onto exceptional faults and ignore the innovative merits (case in point, maddox’s "comparison chart" lists similar resolutions for the iPhone and Nokia E70, conveniently leaving out screen size - size matters, buddy)
Then, there’s the argument that the iPhone doesn’t have GPS, doesn’t have 3G, doesn’t have this, doesn’t have that. Take a moment to refer back to our first counter-point. Then contemplate the fact that the iPhone isn’t hot because it’s packed with features. Damnit, we’ve had technologies like WiFi, touchscreens, music players, video players, web browsing, etc. for years now. But, phones packed with features like 3G, GPS, and WiFi tend to have a “cobbled-together” feel - with a mish-mash feature-set that is neither intuitive, nor seamlessly integrated. The iPhone takes the most necessary and usable features and brings them together in a way that’s efficient and just makes sense. While Multi-Touch is awesome, the Apple iPhone will not usher in a revolution based on its features, but based on the seamless UI - incredibly seamless control melded with intuitive controls that were designed for human interaction. Sure it’s pretty, but the iPhone is about making mobile phones work with the most important interface - the human interface. It’s the UI people, the UI!
And then, there’s the argument that the price of the iPhone is ridiculous. Of course it is - this is A) an Apple product and B) a high-end device. Not everyone wants or needs a $600 mobile phone just because it’s innovative and trendy. Most people just need a phone that makes calls. The iPhone was not made for these people. This first iteration, in whats sure to be a long-lived and fruitful product line, of the iPhone is made for the early adopters out there. Those not afraid of change. Those brave enough to question established doctrine for the sake of change - the never-ending quest to improve the world around us.
As far as maddox’s confusion as to why “Nokia’s marketing team is too busy tossing salad” to get the E70 more coverage, we think we have the answer. They are not “too busy” with anything, maddox. Nokia has simply moved on, likely after the realization that the E70’s design (while strikingly innovative and damn good) was not going to be the market hit that it was intended as. There are other phone’s with that same concept, maddox. They didn’t work out. Just accept it. While being different and enabling change can be good, not all change is good. People just don’t want it as bad as you think they should. In this way, the whole world disagrees - and YOU are wrong.
We’d bet money that maddox seriously lacks the “people-skills” necessary to actually be liked by a group of friends - much less, gain any sort of popularity among peers. Which brings us to our next bet - in watching all the “cool” (yes, the iPhone makes you cool, didn’t you know?) people getting along like sociable human-beings (and “high-fiving each other (literally)”), he built up some serious rage and resentment towards not just the iPhone, but towards the iPhone owners as well (see Mom, that year or two or college psychology really paid off). Which takes us to our final bet - when maddox wakes up a year or two from now and realizes that his new phone took design and functionality (from a UI standpoint, not feature-based) cues from the original iPhone (not to mention the new iPhone that will be on market by that time), he will be forced to renege on his current position and just accept change. Change is good, maddox - it drives innovation (or was it the other way around). In either case, have fun playing with your Nokia E70 by yourself.